Friday, August 1, 2025

HK Season 3

7. Melissa Firpo

Melissa’s run in Hell’s Kitchen is perhaps the first example of a chef starting out as a frontrunner and then just collapsing over a painful three-episode dramatic arc that saw her sent home after a team switch. Up to this point, chefs either started and ended bad or started and ended good. The closest example of a chef starting well and ending poorly is Rachel from season 2, but given the quality of Season 2’s cast, it was more like she started mediocre and ended poorly.

Melissa? Oh, no. Even Ramsay lamp shaded after her team switch that he’d never seen a chef tumble so far. Melissa went from being called best of the worst and asked to nominate two competitors to not even being allowed to plea her case after her last performance. It’s wild, and normally I try to avoid commenting on contestants’ appearance, but here I feel it’s justified as it’s a perfect visual representation of how badly Melissa slipped by the end of her run.

She goes from being very well-groomed, put together and capable to looking and acting like what Ramsay described as a “jumped-up little cavewoman.” Her hair is unkempt, her entire demeanor has shifted towards hostility against the other women, and she has this little burn on her chin. Obviously, it’s just a burn, but a good number of people thought that she was growing a little beard, and given how badly groomed she was at that point, it was shockingly possible. That’s not to insult women who grow facial hair, but combined with her other malfunctions in basic personal upkeep and her plummeting performances it created the impression that she was regressing.

Speaking of her performances, in both challenges and dinner services she went completely unwound. The most notorious example is the shameful duck breast her and her team served to a soon-to-be married couple. But that wouldn’t have happened had Melissa not decided, out of the blue, that she was the red team’s leader, and took it upon herself to put the breast back in the oven because she felt it wasn’t done. This led to it being cooked to shit, her refusing to bring it up several times despite Ramsay’s increasing loss of patience, and when he’s dressing them down afterwards once the guests have left, it’s an early example of him being truly, legitimately angry.

That’s the basic rundown. Melissa would go on to fail at the next service, be switched over to the blue team—much to Rock’s consternation—and then sink on service again, getting sent home before she was even formally nominated.

Nadir: The duck breast incident.

Mitigating factor: I think Melissa is legitimately skilled, she just disintegrated after a few days of little sleep and intense pressure. I base this on the fact that her first service was strong.

6. Brad Miller

Very little to say about this guy. He was the other worthwhile blue team member besides Rock, only being eliminated over Josh because he allowed Josh to sink on the meat station in his last service. I’d love to get a Served Raw for season 3 because I can’t imagine what Ramsay’s motivation for getting rid of Brad over Josh was. Yeah, he wasn’t much of a team player, but, well, we’ll get to Josh soon enough. Let’s just say “sinking” was that dude’s natural state and leave it there for now.

Brad wasn’t a particularly likable guy. He wasn’t as bad as, say, Vinnie or Joanna, but he had a bad habit of shifting blame. He blamed Melissa for his bad service in the final 7, blamed Josh in the final 6, was snarky about Aaron’s sickness, but usually this stuff was aired out in confessionals, not in person. Even when he tried to throw Rock under the bus at an elimination ceremony, he wouldn’t say Rock’s name—Rock had to make him acknowledge who he was talking about. Besides giving Rock the opportunity to beat Walter White to the “say my name” moment, it established that Brad was a bit of a weasel, and Ramsay could likely see that.

Besides that, he was the kind of chef who thought he was a damn sight better than he was. He had control over the blue team’s menu on the create-a-menu service night, at one point trying to sell off a mac ‘n’ cheese dish as a fancier item called a “cassoulet.” In fact, let’s go with that. Brad, in one sentence, is a mac ‘n’ cheese who thought he was a cassoulet.

Nadir: Mocking Aaron in the confessional booth. “I’d like to see Aaron get better. Uh, get better at cooking.” Fuck you, Brad.

Mitigating factor: Chef Ramsay noted that Brad was a hard worker.

5. Josh Wahler

In the most recent 10 or 15 seasons of Hell’s Kitchen, the black jackets have gone from being a combination of the last few chefs still standing in a season to this elite club, to the point where there’s a black jacket lounge, there’s a special set of challenges for getting the jacket, and contestants act as if getting a black jacket is akin to getting a Michelin star. Maybe it’s a bit more justified in the later seasons, where the competition is a lot more fierce and even chefs that are in the bottom half of the final rankings at least have some moments of brilliance. But to me, the idea is always laughable. Black jackets are no guarantee of culinary brilliance, and that leads me to Josh, the single worst black jacket contestant in the show’s history, probably forever.

Since I’m about to run down all of this dude’s failures, I’ll at least point out his most positive trait: his attitude. He’s never instigating any drama with his team like Melissa, he doesn’t harbor grudges when chefs like Rock and Brad question his abilities, he always tries his best and never talks back to chef in service, saving it for the confessional booth, and even at his most arrogant and deluded, he’s still likable. I can absolutely see why Ramsay kept him around for a little while.

…To a certain extent.

Because this dude was a trainwreck from start to finish. The gulf between his perception of his abilities and the reality is enough to give the Grand Canyon the appearance of an empty bowl of dog food, and if Josh made dog food and put it in said bowl, the dog wouldn’t eat it.

Nadir: Most of us would choose his mid-service ejection, but I think the challenge earlier in that episode is a much better example. In the DVD release of Season 3, the full results are revealed, and out of 100 high-schoolers, not a single one of them voted for Josh’s salmon with pineapple salsa. I repeat—one hundred high-schoolers, none of them preferred his dish. In a sample size of 100, a bowl full of deep-fried sheep anuses basted in sewage runoff could get at least one fucking vote. It makes me want to taste the dish Josh made, just to understand how the hell he pulled this off—it’s impressive in the same way getting zero on a multiple-choice test is impressive, because you have to know enough about what the right answers are to avoid guessing them. Is Josh some kind of reverse-savant who can make anything taste too bad to be palatable, in a world where there are people who drink coffee made with beans picked from cat shit?

Sunday, July 27, 2025

HK Season 2

 

A person who got introduced to Hell’s Kitchen with one of the modern seasons would expect Season 1 of Hell’s Kitchen to look like this instead of what it looked like. Season 2 is when the show began to resemble itself as it would go on to exist, with the documentary style of Season 1 falling to the wayside in favor of bigger drama, bigger music, more outlandish contestants, and an all-around bigger emphasis on personality and style as opposed to the mechanics of cooking and running a restaurant.

This, fans generally agree, is to the show’s benefit. Let’s face it, if we wanted to learn about running a restaurant and cooking on a line, we’d either go do research or if we insisted on learning from a TV show, marathon Kitchen Nightmares’ UK version. And THEN do research, because that still wouldn’t get the job done. But for Hell’s Kitchen, we want donkeys and wankers getting bollocked and buggered. And here are 12 more of Ramsay’s hapless victims.

12. Polly Holladay

A dictionary-standard definition of a first boot, Polly was on the older side of this season’s age range, got kicked off her station after multiple failed attempts at the very first dish of the night, cooked Chef Ramsay a signature dish that wasn’t cooked, and enjoys a reputation centered more around what she failed to do than what she really did. Sweeping the floor after being designated the kitchen donkey was likely her only beneficial action during her truncated stint in Hell’s Kitchen. Narratively, she did little else but get out of the way so that Heather could establish herself as the clear frontrunner as early as possible, as once Heather took over her station, the red kitchen finally churned out an appetizer.

Nadir: I have one chance to impress the greatest chef in the world, so here, have some bread that maybe glanced sideways at a stove one time for a couple minutes. It’s a gutsy move, I’ll admit, to NOT cook your signature dish. I could have gone on Hell’s Kitchen and put a half-loaf of Mrs. Baird’s under a dome with a lit match and it would have equaled Polly’s effort.

Mitigating factor: She took all of Ramsay’s vitriol like a champ. I suppose she did have six sons naturally—which, holy shit. How do you have six kids and all of them are the same gender, what are you, Namekian?

11. Larry Sik

It must have taken Hell’s Kitchen’s casting director ages to find a dude with the last name Sik who was certain to have health problems at some point in the show. Or, at least, that’s what I thought, until I did some research and saw that Larry’s actual last name is “Ross.” So why in hell did he go by “Sik”—first off, who even has a surname nickname? Second, did he choose the name “Sik” because he knew he was going to get sick with a mystery illness after the first dinner service? Did God watch a guy nickname himself “Sik” before working in a high-pressure kitchen and decide to just call his bluff?

I seriously can’t get over how ridiculous this contestant gets the more I think about them. He’s like 5’4 and Chef Ramsay compared him to the Statue of Liberty, he’s the first black contestant in the show’s history AS WELL AS the show’s first med-evac, his last action before getting too sick to continue was to flirt with a lesbian and a newlywed in a hot-tub (yeah, I know, Heather’s married to a guy now, she identified as lesbian during her time on the show), he did absolutely nothing during his only service except fuck up like, one dish, if Served Raw is any indication. I don’t even remember what his signature dish was, I just know it was bad, because the only guy who did have a well-received signature dish is a 21-year-old Italian whose other notable accomplishment is triggering Ramsay with his goddamn hair. All of this is to say, I need to travel to the alternate dimension where Larry made it to the final five, I swear.

Nadir: Flirting with Heather and Virginia while he was already feeling sick.

Mitigating factor: Flirting with Heather and Virginia while he was already feeling sick.

10. Gabe Gagliardi

When Gabe found out Larry was eliminated due to his health, he told him before hanging up, “tonight’s service is for you.” Gabe then proceeded to have one of the worst services of the entire season and obtain the distinction of being the first ever person eliminated despite his team not even fucking nominating him. His service was so bad, it probably made Larry even more sick.

To see how bad this dude’s service was, you have to watch the second Served Raw video. The only impression you get of him in the edited version of his service is that he thought Ramsay needed a quail when he didn’t, then getting his station taken over by other teammates. What the episode probably DIDN’T show you is that his station was filthy, he kept shutting down and not responding, needed goddamn TOM to help him remember orders, Ramsay had to give him a risotto lesson like two hours into service and just kept having to babysit him and remind him to talk for the entire service—everything that a chef could possibly do wrong on this show, he basically did. He probably would have sent raw chicken if one of his dishes included chicken.

Nadir: Bringing Ramsay nearly to tears in his last service just by ignoring him.

Mitigating factor: He did feel sympathetic to Larry for having to leave due to illness. It doesn’t sound like much, but it’s more than can be said for chefs in future seasons.

9. Giacomo Alfieri

A lot of chefs wound up in Ramsay’s crosshairs during the first five seasons, where it seems like he would look for any reason to badger and belittle them. These will be discussed as they come, but perhaps the first example of someone who just couldn’t avoid getting a mudhole stomped into his ass every chance Ramsay got was Giacomo.

In this case, I’m positive that Ramsay hammered Giacomo so much because he had the best signature dish. Sometimes, if Ramsay’s got his foot up your ass constantly to the point where you start feeling like a shoe wearing a chef’s jacket, it’s because he’s driving you to be as good as he thinks you might be. What was later revealed in an interview, and what Chef completely failed to catch, is that Giacomo’s pasta dish was using pre-packaged pasta, something that is verboten on this show. When I learned about this, I came up with a second theory as to why Ramsay rode Giacomo so much—he figured out about the pre-packaged pasta later and, infuriated that Giacomo got something like that past his palate, decided to give him the worst three or four days of his life before eliminating him.

So yeah, this hapless bastard got his hair-do insulted, got called dirt-brain, donkey, dick, a goon, told he was poncing around, harangued by Chef Scott for not having his oven on, and to his credit, he took it all to the best of his ability, especially considering he was just barely old enough to drink and had no idea what a lot of the stuff he was cooking with even was. By the time he left the show, he must’ve felt just as much relief as disappointment.

Nadir: Chef Scott bitching him out about his stove being off. Ramsay yells at you because he cares, but Chef Scott yells at you because he has mostly bile and malice running through his veins.

Mitigating factor: Probably the only chef in the show’s history who fooled Chef Ramsay with pre-packaged ingredients.

8. Tom Pauley (Poley)

Before I start, this chef did recently pass away. So please keep in mind that none of these are meant as personal attacks. The only thing I know about this man is what the editors of Hell’s Kitchen showed me, so when I start writing about this guy, keep in mind it’s less about him and more about the product that resulted from how the show used his footage.

Anyway, to begin with, the show cared so little about this guy and his dignity, they didn’t even bother to spell his last name right. Let that just set the tone for you.

Tom’s talent was how well he could sell himself, which was enough in this cast of chefs to make him the third strongest among the men. This is either a positive take on his speaking skills or a scathing indictment of the degree of talent this season had going for it. Personally, I fall in both of those camps.

Beyond his relatively strong elimination pleas, Tom’s accomplishments mostly involved helping to make Chef Ramsay sound like he was going to start weeping at any minute. Ramsay was angry in Season 1, and sometimes contestants clearly got to him there, but here in Season 2 the casting department had figured out what would make for entertaining meltdowns and they narrowed the field down with quantum precision. That’s the only way I can explain how Tom managed to make it on the show at all, never mind how far he made it, because the dude could do no right, and Ramsay probably aged 10 years over one month of trying over and over to help him attain any degree of competence. That is, when he wasn’t breaking Tom’s balls for acting like he was in the movie Martyrs every time he cut or burned himself.

Nadir: Seemingly declaring that Chef Ramsay, a confirmed blackbelt, doesn’t want to get into a street fight with him during a confessional. I say “seemingly” because the way it was edited makes it seem like he could have been talking about any other male presence on the show.

Mitigating factor: Saying “if he didn’t care, he wouldn’t break my chops” after Ramsay savaged his signature dish. Say what you will about Tom, he had a better understanding of how Ramsay worked than many other early contestants.

7. Rachel Brown

Once again, I must preface by saying that this chef has died since their season aired. She died under very tragic circumstances not long after being on the show, so I am going to tread lightly here.

Rachel started off as one of the prospective leaders in the red kitchen, quickly forming a tight bond with Heather and a rivalry with Sara. However, once Heather got moved over to the blue kitchen, a switch seemed to go off in her head and she started to snowball downhill, with Ramsay at one point even taking her into the pantry to try and wake her up with a pep talk, which I’m pretty sure is the first time he ever did that. Usually, when he does that, it either means that you’re having an unusually bad run or you’re in danger of being eliminated in the middle of service. Rachel, I think, was in the former.

I think Rachel is one of the first examples of somebody starting off spot lighted as a legitimate frontrunner and totally collapsing way earlier than they should have. Chefs like Melissa from the third season and Anton from twelve would have a similar arc. If Rachel kept it consistent, she might have been in the final two with Heather instead of Virginia. Sadly, she was unable to do that because of nerves that led to her being unable to recover when she made one mistake.

Nadir: Sending up massively overcooked lamb wellingtons and then beating herself up back at her station. Becomes really painful to watch given what happened after the show aired.

Mitigating factor: Offering to take the place of one of her teammates on the chopping block if Ramsay thought she deserved to go over them.

6. Maribel Miller

Maribel is someone I feel people sleep on a little bit. This might be because I saw an interview of hers where she showed more of her personality, but in a season where people are starting to show early signs of being picked for drama as opposed to competence, Maribel just feels like someone who is trying to make it to the end of the day. That’s not to say she ever had a chance to win, I don’t think anyone but Heather was winning this season, but Maribel sometimes feels like a stand-in for the audience with how she reacts to Chef Ramsay’s insults and jabs. This is especially true in Served Raw, where we often hear her laugh or talk back to Ramsay and Sous Chef Maryann, not necessarily with attitude, just casually. Like, it never felt like she was intimidated to be there.

One interesting thing she said in that aforementioned interview was that she was eliminated because she requested the producers to send her home due to being homesick. Normally, when chefs voluntarily quit the show, we see it—which, now that I think about it, that’s a dumb sentence, because of course I’m not going to know about the voluntary eliminations the show doesn’t tell me about—anyway, she quit due to homesickness and as soon as she got back home she was asked to come back for the finale, which she declined, giving us the gift of more Giacomo in the finale. Not much else to say beyond all that, I just recommend Served Raw if you want to see Maribel having a little more personality than she does in the edited show.

Nadir: Doing so badly during one service that a table walked out after waiting two hours for entrees. Upon being called useless for this, Maribel responds under her breath with, “I love you, too, man.”

Mitigating factor: One bit that lives rent free in my head is in Served Raw when Maribel imitates Ramsay saying “wakey wakey” under her breath. She’s lucky Ramsay didn’t hear that, as we all know from Boris’s example several seasons later.

5. Garrett Telle

The more I go through these chefs, the more I realize how much every single one of them got yelled at throughout the season. It’s especially noticeable by the final five, where you can’t help but wonder how these people got as far as they did. Really one of the weakest casts in the show’s history, and it shows by the fact that Garrett, who would be an early boot on a season with two digits in it, makes it to fifth place.

Garrett at least is an interesting personality. A fine example is that he almost immediately clashed with Heather over a sexist joke he made that, honestly, I think Heather blew out of proportion. Garrett was clearly being ironic with the “have our dinner ready” comment, considering he was folding laundry while saying it, not to mention the goofy-ass way he said it. At the same time, I do get where Heather’s coming from, because as it’s mentioned in the season, women do have to work much harder than men to gain the same amount of respect.

Garrett’s most noticeable trait is his anger. Between him and Keith, this was one of the saltiest blue teams ever. It’s little wonder that the finale was two women, because every male this season was either an asshole, incompetent, or an incompetent asshole, and unfortunately Garrett hits in the middle of that Venn diagram. He serves raw chicken in his final episode, which, okay, imagine if your doctor prescribed you Tylenol 4 but the pharmacist accidentally gave you carfentanyl. That’s pretty much what we’re looking at here. Raw chicken can and will kill a person, particularly if they’re immunocompromised, so it’s little wonder Garrett got sent home and was subsequently picked last in the finale—though this can be chalked up to some unbelievably poor strategizing that we’ll get to when it’s that chef’s turn.

Nadir: Flipped off Ramsay accidentally, not realizing he was in the car with the women on their reward.

Mitigating factor: Singing “turbot, salmon, wellington,” during service, which inexplicably was left out of the actual show. Seriously, anyone watching this who hasn’t seen Served Raw, go watch that shit, it’s incredible.

4. Sara Horowitz

Here’s someone I would consider to be the show’s first true villain. Somebody who was willing to sabotage her teammate, or at least take joy in having made them look bad, and somebody who just caused all sorts of unnecessary drama with her teammates, especially Rachel and Virginia.

Some of it was also in her immaturity. For example, goofing around, dancing, and doing helium impersonations of Chef Ramsay during a punishment led to her and Rachel having a rivalry that lasted until the latter was out the door. It also led to Maryann spiking a cake into the ground like it was a goddamn touchdown. At least, I think it did, Maryann may have just done that because she was pissed off in general. That’s something worth observing about her, she clearly hated being there for her three-season run as a sous chef. Working with people like Sara probably brought out the worst in her. It brought out the worst in Ramsay, too, and I’m amazed she didn’t get screamed at for farting during the photo-shoot reward when Chef was like a couple of feet away from her. More like photo-shit.

Finally, we have to talk about the incident with the lamb at the final six. I guarantee you Maribel’s homesickness was the only reason Sara survived this shit, because oh my god, this has to be the worst outcome of any create your own menu service in the show’s history to this day. Sara brags up this lamb dish she made while working at a restaurant that was so good, she was fired. For anyone who listens carefully, this is like telling someone the reason you failed a test is because you got a score larger than 100, so it scrolled over back to 1. Anyway, Sara’s dish winds up on the menu only for her to absolutely fuck it up during service, to the point where Ramsay 86es it. Keep in mind, a rack of lamb is expensive, so for Ramsay to watch Sara tooling around with poorly cut lambchops like she’s playing goddamn solitaire must’ve been akin to watching someone piss into a garbage bag full of money. But hey, she was learning, Chef!

Nadir: Getting called a “fat-mouthed little stupid bitch” later in the aforementioned lamb service because she argued with Ramsay over consistency.

Mitigating factor: The service where Heather burned herself, Sara, having been assigned to waiting tables, asked Ramsay if she could come into the kitchen, which he agreed to, and this led to a shot of Sara ripping her waitress shirt off like goddamn Superman.

3. Keith Greene

Another chef from this season who has since passed, so I must once again preface by saying that I’m not criticizing the person, I’m criticizing the edit of that person that Hell’s Kitchen gives us.

K-Grease, much like Jon from Season 11, was the lone shining star of a very weak men’s team. Also like Jon from Season 11, he failed to make the final two because he shit the bed running the pass. Which is really strange, you’d figure a guy with a personality like his, who had been working with Heather since almost the beginning of the competition, would be able to lead. But he always shut down, and what kills him in the end isn’t so much his weakness as a leader, but his seeming unwillingness to lead.

Keith is perhaps best known for his shade thrown at Chef Ramsay for picking Virginia over him in the final two, and in fairness, Virginia was winning challenges constantly and surviving shit service after shit service, at one point having immunity, only to have it taken away during dinner service and then promptly returned once on the chopping block. It did feel, at times, like Virginia was being railroaded into the finale at the expense of other, more consistent chefs. He could have chosen better phrasing than “you have a hard-on for Virginia,” but he’s far from the only one who thinks he was robbed that season. Personally, it’s like I said earlier, nobody but Heather was winning this season, so the other person in the final two was always just going to be fodder.

Overall, Keith as a contestant has a unique blend of having a serious attitude problem while also being a very endearing guy at times. His friendship with Heather is charming, his closest brush with drama was when he took Virginia on a reward with him when he already agreed to take Garrett on any rewards during black jackets, and Chef Ramsay even told him that he could be a great chef if he’d just learn to take criticism and be a leader. Sadly, we’ll never know how good he could have been.

Nadir: Demanding money from Virginia before he would work for her in the finale. Yeah, Virginia probably shouldn’t have been in the final two, but if you didn’t want to possibly work for her, you shouldn’t have come back.

Mitigating factor: As I mentioned earlier, welcoming Heather into the blue team and forming a legitimate bond with her. It’s fun to watch the two of them goofing around in the dorms or during rewards.

2. Virginia Dalbeck

The most controversial chef in this season, Virginia tends to split fans down the middle. Not literally, like she’s goddamn Samurai Jack, but some people fall into Camp Keith and others into Camp Virginia. It’s generally agreed that Virginia is a strong chef if you task her with doing a single dish, or maybe a few of the same dish for a group of construction workers, but it’s when you put her on the line that her weaknesses become readily apparent.

Along with Bonnie from Season 3 and Scott from Season 12, Virginia is maybe one of the worst line cooks ever to make it into the final two. Her single good service at the final seven aside, she was put up for elimination by her team every time they lost, and almost every single time it was warranted. Nobody who wants to win this show wants the kind of record Virginia has in service. It’s like she signed up for MasterChef and went to the wrong studio.

That’s not to say that Virginia ever had a bad attitude or ever gave up. Quite the opposite, she kept trying even if she was immune from elimination, or if it would have been to her benefit to let someone sink, and I think her much more positive, malleable nature played a big part in her beating out Keith for runner-up.

One thing we need to discuss is how bad she did on her final night. First off, this woman won the final individual challenge and was rewarded with first pick. Out of a returning cast including Keith, Sara, Garrett, Rachel, Tom and Giacomo, Virginia snatched Keith, then took Tom and Giacomo. I repeat—this goddamn woman had FIRST PICK, she was set to DICTATE how Heather’s team was going to look, and not only did she pick the one guy who hates her, even if he was very talented and would have been a great boon to Heather’s team, she picks TOM as her second pick and fucking GIACOMO as her third, passing up the other black jackets she could have easily had since Heather’s first pick was Rachel! It’s as if Virginia thought that by choosing to play the game on Very Hard difficulty, Ramsay would give her the win out of respect or something, ignoring the fact that the men she picked must COOK.

But, no, we aren’t done yet. Not even close. Virginia meets up with her team outside later, where she point-blank tells these two men, Tom and Giacomo, that they are weak, that she picked them to make a point to Chef about her leadership qualities, and that Keith was going to be picking up their slack. This is like a coach walking into the locker room and telling his players, “you’re here because you suck ass and everyone knows it, but if you go out there and win for me, I will look like a GOD for getting anything out of you worthless jerks. Now GET ON THE FIELD!” This is exactly the reason why Keith corkscrewed Virginia into paying each of them a grand to help her win—how can she possibly have thought this was anything other than a horrible idea?

So, predictably, Heather goes on to defeat Virginia in the finale, in one of the most obvious landslides in the show’s history. To this day, speaking purely talent-wise, this is the biggest gap between two finalists. But, to end on a more positive note, Virginia took her loss with grace and admitted that Heather deserved it, and when Virginia returned for a service against the black jackets of Season 10, she was much stronger on the line, showing a great deal of growth that only someone with a positive outlook and willingness to learn could show.

Nadir: Sending Ramsay burst tortellini, then telling him she would serve that in her restaurant. Ramsay has to ask her two or three more times if she would really serve that, practically begging her to give the right answer, until eventually she stares at the dish for a few seconds and declares she will try again. All Ramsay can muster up in his exhaustion is “I think that’s a really sensible idea.” This is the kind of shit that would get somebody tossed in the middle of service nowadays.

Mitigating factor: On the night she was told to nominate two of her team, when Ramsay asks her for her second nominee, Virginia goes on this super-long spiel about how Sara screwed her over a few services ago by lying about some turbot… and then doesn’t nominate her, opting for Maribel to go up with Rachel. This earns her praise from Chef Ramsay. Take that as a lesson if you’re ever on Hell’s Kitchen—you should always nominate the chefs who are objectively the worst instead of the ones you don’t like.

1. Heather West

Finally, we arrive at this season’s only unmistakably great chef, and the only person who could lead a kitchen. Virginia was too scatterbrained, Keith was too lackadaisical, Sara was too much of a backstabber, and Garrett straight-up served raw chicken. No, Heather was the only one who could do the job, and Ramsay clearly saw that, because at no point did it feel like she was in serious danger of elimination, when every other chef, save for perhaps Keith, had several appointments with the chopping block.

Heather has the distinction of being the first Hell’s Kitchen contestant to come back as a sous chef during a future season, being the red team’s sous chef for Season 6. Given how terribly Season 6’s red team performed, it doesn’t surprise me that she didn’t return for future services. That said, Heather is still among the most respectable winners in Hell’s Kitchen history, holding her own against sexist comments and backstabbing teammates, absolutely crushing the pass, and also just being a total adorable goofball during her Season 2 run. She’s so much fun at times, it’s hard to imagine she’s also a total hardass leader, and that’s what makes her great—she knows when and when not to let her cute, chilled-out side out. Ramsay gave her a hard time in Season 2 as he did with everyone else, but it never felt like he gave up on her.

Nadir: When she lost the construction worker challenge. Her reaction to taking such a low place is heartbreaking, it’s obvious she felt it on a personal level.

Mitigating factor: Coordinating dishes with her team while suffering from a terribly serious burn that wound up landing her in the hospital. I bet this is the exact moment where Ramsay decided she was the winner.

CONCLUSION:

Season 2’s cast is weaker than the cast of Season 1, in terms of talent. Even though Heather is still one of the strongest winners in the series, the other chefs are either untalented or flawed so deeply they never had a chance. It’s going to be a pleasure to enter the later seasons and see some of the real nail-biter finales.

Friday, July 25, 2025

In Which I Discuss the Contestants of Hell's Kitchen Season 1

 Season 1 of Hell’s Kitchen is often considered the strangest season of the show, not so much because it’s different structurally—it still follows largely the same format and most of what it established did carry over to future seasons—but because it’s tonally very quiet and lowkey. The music is very muted, the contestants aren’t depicted in an over-the-top manner, and Chef Ramsay comes across as much less cartoonish. This has the advantage of making him more menacing because his anger feels more genuine, but it also makes him a whole lot less memorable and meme-able. In general, the whole thing feels like a transition from the relaxed documentary style of Ramsay’s UK shows and the absurdly scored and edited American counterparts.

Having said that, there is still a lot of fun to be had from watching these early episodes, and there are contestants that still get talked about in the show’s sizable fandom. So, uh, let’s do more talking about them.

12. Carolann Valentino

For me, this contestant’s greatest role in the series is to establish the unpredictability of Chef Ramsay’s eliminations. We are introduced to Carolann through her signature dish, which along with Elsie’s was the only one to receive good marks. Anyone watching this show live at the time it aired probably figured Carolann was going to either win or make it several episodes in. But nope, she completely fizzles out, being a non-presence during dinner service and being the first elimination nominee in the show’s history, alongside Dewberry.

I still wonder about Carolann in terms of how much farther she could have gotten if she had been given another chance. Yeah, we wouldn’t have gotten the infamous moment with Dewberry, but maybe someone who already had showed some promise during the signature dishes would have put in some work upon getting more accustomed to working in a fine-dining kitchen.

Nadir: Being the very first person eliminated from the show, not because she was bad at cooking, but because she… didn’t.

Mitigating factor: Has easily one of the most interesting post-Hell’s Kitchen turns in life. Seriously, look into it.

11. Jeffery Dewberry

Though Carolann was the first to hand her jacket over, Dewberry’s subsequent downfall was so infamous that it still, to this day, is considered an iconic moment in the show, and demonstrates another hard rule in Ramsay’s kitchen—don’t walk off the goddamn line. Don’t even ACT like you’re about to walk off the line. Until Ramsay tells you to get out, you don’t go anywhere until the service ends.

Dewberry was clearly not suited for this environment to begin with—this was during the first season, where Ramsay absolutely hated fat people and was not shy about expressing that. On top of that, the pressure on the meat station got to Dewberry, and I mean Lacey-style. He could cook spaghetti, and that’s about it. Soon as Ramsay put him over on proteins, man folded like some damn laundry. A shame too, because he seemed like a very nice guy, probably another reason why he wasn’t going to make it.

Nadir: Almost walking off the line, which resulted directly in his elimination.

Mitigating factor: Uttered this amazing quote when he returned for the final service: “I’d rather you be saying I was Brad Pitt’s wife.” If you can crack up Chef Scott, you’re on to something special.

10. Jeff LaPoff

The biggest asshole in a season largely absent of them, Jeff started off weak and just got weaker while a kidney stone shot his attitude through the roof. Now, I can relate, I’ve had a couple kidney stones in my day and they hurt like hell, but once he pissed out the thing, it seemed to make him even worse. It was as if Jeff pissed all the niceness out of his body in the form of a tiny rock, because he became perpetually butthurt for the remainder of his short time on the show. Fought with his teammates over nothing, screamed at his sous chef, called Ramsay an asshole and walked off in a huff, unceremoniously ending the show’s first villain arc.

Now, is he wrong that Ramsay’s an asshole? No, he isn’t. But that’s also the point, and that little fact fled Jeff’s head if it was ever there to begin with. If he’d have just put his head down and kept trying, he might have survived his last night on the show, especially because Hell’s Kitchen never saw a villain they didn’t want to keep around for way too long. But because this Napoleon-complex jerkoff couldn’t handle Ramsay’s brutal honesty, he not only walked off the line and the show, he straight-up tried to confront Ramsay after service and fell down, hurting his ankle, and limped away with a $100,000 out of-court settlement.

…Huh. Well, shit, maybe he got the good end of the deal after all. Even the winner of the damn show only gets a quarter million. I wonder how much these producers would pay me to break my ankle?

Nadir: Getting owned by Chef Maryann moments before his departure.

Mitigating factor: Somehow corkscrewing money out of FOX because he fell down. Yeah, I know there was probably more to the situation and a lot of the money would have been eaten up by legal fees, but he still got the network to pay out.

9. Wendy Liu

Now that a couple of the more entertaining screw-ups have left the building, we’re at the point of the season where the garden-variety donkeys are being culled, starting with Wendy. Fans of the show might recognize her as, “who?” Super fans of the show will recognize her as the lady who thought cold water boiled faster than hot water. This coming from somebody who referred to herself at least once as a “perfectionist.” Believing that cold boils faster than hot is on the same level as believing that yelling at dirt until it leaves your house is faster than vacuuming. It’s awe-inspiringly ridiculous.

We don’t really see her interact much with other contestants, beyond being pleasant and congenial with everyone. She did teach Ralph and other members of the blue team how to say “we won’t lose again” in Mandarin, another thing she said that was incorrect because the blue team most certainly would lose more challenges from this point.

Nadir: Not knowing what the hell “hot” and “cold” mean while working in a kitchen.

Mitigating factor: Nice person. Jessica cried after she was eliminated, but she did that after damn near every female elimination, so maybe that’s not so special.

8. Mary-Ellen Daniels

Maybe the first elimination in the history of the show that reeked of bullshit, Mary-Ellen was put up alongside Andrew who had been a source of pain in Chef’s ass since all the way back in signature dishes. Mary-Ellen barely made any mark on the season for the time she was present, the only thing I can remember her for is calling out Andrew for telling Ramsay that she had done something or showed her something incorrectly, I don’t even remember and I already stopped caring halfway through this sentence. Maybe the blandest chef in this entire season, she didn’t come back for the final service and I can honestly say I wouldn’t have noticed if she had.

Nadir: Ugh. Whatever the hell she did during her last service to get her thrown out.

Mitigating factor: Was one of the many, many people who shouted at Andrew.

7. Chris North

A bullshit elimination owed entirely to the fact that Ramsay couldn’t override nominations in Season 1, or if he could, he chose not to. Chris made an immediate impression on Ramsay with his signature dish and his title as Executive Chef. It was not a good impression—his salmon was raw, served on a plank which just opened up an opportunity to insult them, then proceeded to take a spanking every time he so much as breathed too loudly in Ramsay’s presence. Michael, the season’s eventual winner and the man who broke the show, took note of this and decided to nominate him and put him against Elsie, a chef that Ramsay saw great potential in. It was truly a bastard move, made that much more brilliant by the fact that it worked.

Was Chris ever going to win the season? Doubtful. Ramsay hated him too much to let him survive over Michael or Ralph even IF he managed to stay over Elsie. Much like Mary-Ellen, Chris would not return for the finale, probably because Ramsay put a sign on the front of Hell’s Kitchen reading “NO EXECUTIVE CHEFS ALLOWED” before anyone could even ask him, and he will forevermore be known as the elimination that most likely spurred Ramsay being able to veto nominations in future seasons.

Nadir: Submitting a bad dish in the first service and getting the plate smashed into his chest.

Mitigating factor: Building up a good working relationship with Elsie not long before they were nominated together.

6. Andrew Bonito

If you want an example of how chefs coming on this show have improved in quality, try to remember the last time a chef came in 6th place and wasn’t at least complimented a little bit on the way out the door. Season 13, maybe? Season 9? No clue. But I tell you what, you know a cast is made up of amateurs when half of them are gone and Ramsay is still eliminating chefs that he says straight-up “can’t cook.” If Andrew can’t cook, and he almost made it into black jackets, what the hell was with the five who left before him? Did they mean to get on Survivor and went to the wrong goddamn studio?

Andrew is an early example of a chef who consistently dealt everyone some bullshit and slipped by week after week. I mentioned earlier that Chris was a possible catalyst for Ramsay gaining the privilege of eliminating anyone whenever he wants, but Andrew is also a contender, because I know it was chapping Ramsay’s ass that Andrew was almost on the black team.

To put into perspective the thickness of this guy’s douche fumes, he said in episode one during a confessional that if cooking doesn’t work out, he’s going into politics. This guy’s sterling personality, I’m stunned that wasn’t his first choice. Dewberry would have had more luck becoming a yoga instructor. As for his cooking, all you need to know is that this man served a risotto to a customer that made them puke. I’ve scoured the ingredients of this dish, and I can’t find anything that would make somebody vomit if added in overabundance. This guy is on some Squidward levels of cooking ability.

Nadir: Deciding to not rat out Ralph for the steak-and-peaches fiasco the one time when being a loudmouth might have helped him.

Mitigating factor: Put in an honorable effort during the final service, working through an injury when chefs from other seasons would have whined the entire time.

5. Jimmy Casey

Known by his nicknames “Dirty Bowl Jimmy” and “fat fuck,” not to be confused with every other fat person ever on Hell’s Kitchen, Jimmy has the inauspicious distinction of being the first black jacket chef eliminated from the show. For those of you who don’t know what black jacket means, once there are only five or six people left between both teams, the teams get combined. By the time you get to roughly season 12 or 13, getting a black jacket is treated with the same reverence as being promoted to Jesus at wherever you work.

Which is why it’s so funny to see the kinds of people who make black jackets early in the show, and Jimmy is one such example. From the very first episode, this dude screwed up at least once or twice an episode, and Ramsay himself stated he would never be a great chef because he was too fat and clumsy. Granted, part of that is just because Ramsay treated fat people in early seasons of Hell’s Kitchen worse than that one Black Mirror episode with the goddamn treadmills, but Jimmy actually was a total clod, and it was by sheer luck of nominations that he made it as far as he did.

Ramsay did tell Jimmy that he should be proud of how far he came, and that he did well, but for me that just feels like a backhanded compliment. Like, it sounds like he’s saying, “you should be proud that you managed to make it as far as you did, given your debilitating fatness and having only a thimbleful of talent.” Maybe I’m just projecting, though.

Nadir: Submitting a bad dish in the first service and getting the plate smashed into his chest.

Mitigating factor: Winning the first individual challenge in the history of Hell’s Kitchen and getting a bitchin’ helicopter ride for his trouble.

4. Elsie Ramos

There are occasions in this show’s long and storied history where Ramsay will take a liking to a particular contestant and take a gentler tack with them than he might with another person making the same mistake. These people typically don’t win the contest, but they win the chef’s heart and that is a victory in itself, especially if Ramsay decides to, say, put them through culinary school or offer them a chance to work in London for him.

Elsie didn’t get any kind of special recognition like that, but she did win Ramsay over almost immediately by being humble and demonstrating natural ability in a cast full of people who were either very experienced coming in or totally incompetent. Her lack of fine-dining experience would defeat her in black jackets, but she was a favorite of both the viewing public and the Chef himself, putting up honest, simple dishes during challenges and giving it her best effort during services. Notably, she was the first ever contestant to be crowned Best of the Worst, she took an individual challenge out from under the likes of Michael, Ralph and Jessica, and even though two of those three would go on to let her sink in her final service, Ramsay clearly knew it wasn’t all her fault even as he eliminated her for just not being ready yet.

So, yeah. Very little negative to say about this chef. I think her very presence gave Ramsay a chance to show, even in the season where he arguably was at his most intimidating and ruthless, he had a heart, and that humanized him enough for people in America that they’ve let Hell’s Kitchen stick around for two decades now.

Nadir: If the edit we were shown in the first episode is accurate, and who knows if it is, then her nominating Dewberry in episode 1 after assuring him he wasn’t going home that night is pretty shady. But Dewberry did forgive her, and it was probably the right thing to do since he nearly quit the very next service.

Mitigating factor: Being noble and not throwing the final three under the bus when Ramsay asked if she had the support of her team. Some might call that a dumb move, and I do get that because this is a competition, but calling out the other three also would have made her look like she was blaming everyone else for her own very lacking experience. I think she went home on the right night for her.

3. Jessica Cabo

Jessica is one of those classic examples of a contestant who starts off pretty strong but gets to the black jackets and just deteriorates. Not only that, but she gets into a couple of loud confrontations with Chef Ramsay, which depending on how strong you are might make you “a passionate chef” or “a disrespectful ass,” it varies from contestant to contestant. The one where she tells Chef she only has two beef left is a distinctly memorable one, with the way he mocks the hell out of her during that entire exchange, between her hand gestures and her general whininess.

That’s really Jessica’s most noteworthy trait for me, honestly, and I’m glad she didn’t make it to the finals. She was just not really likable—a good example of this is early in the season when she notices Jeff curled up on the ground as he’s suffering from a kidney stone and when he’s in too much pain to immediately tell her what’s wrong with him, she just goes “whatever” and walks off. Now, that “whatever” sounds really spliced-in, so I may be off-base, but even if nobody liked Jeff, the dude was in the fetal position for fuck’s sake, it’s worth at least asking him a couple more times before just walking off.

Nadir: Backstabbing Elsie after the final four challenge, after being best buds with her for the entire competition beforehand.

Mitigating factor: The punk rock spiked hair-do looks good on her.

2. Ralph Pagano

Maybe my favorite person from this season, even if he was a bit slimy for helping Elsie’s downfall. And, I guess, for letting Andrew take the hit on that grilled peaches fiasco, but I don’t think Andrew ever had a chance of surviving past Ralph in any case. But yeah, Ralph’s the most charismatic chef of the season by a considerable margin, he’s funny but he knows when it’s time to lay the hammer down, and even if he did let some bad shit go by him at the pass thanks to Michael’s sabotage, I still think he was a better leader. He just had a bigger voice.

I think Ramsay ultimately passed him up for winner because Michael was younger and, let’s be honest, pretty damn smart. That, and Ralph kind of boned himself over by letting Michael pick Jimmy and Elsie so he could instead work with Andrew, who was a wild card given how the two clashed, and Wendy, who doesn’t fucking know what “hot” means. Andrew wound up working out much better than anyone could’ve expected, Wendy seemed to do okay as well, but Ralph unfortunately had last pick and so was given Dewberry, who did his best but had to leave the kitchen for a large portion of service due to exhaustion.

Still, Ralph went on to have much more success in culinary than his opponent, so you can’t feel bad about him losing.

Nadir: Biffing the blind taste test challenge by destroying his palate earlier that day with coffee, cigarettes and cold drops. You know, the three C’s.

1. Michael Wray

There will never be another winner of Hell’s Kitchen like Michael Wray. Some have come a little close, like Ariel M. or Michelle (some would argue), but Michael was unique in how cunning and ruthless he was. This man came in like Akagi from Kaiji, analyzing the weaknesses of the show’s format and exploiting them to his advantage. Going back over my comments on the other contestants, several of them fell victim to Michael’s cutthroat tactics. He didn’t assist in letting Elsie sink, to his credit, but he did put Chris up with her against Ramsay for elimination, knowing Ramsay wouldn’t be willing to part ways with a chef as promising as Elsie. And you can thank Michael for many bad pass runs in future seasons, because he was the one who came up with sending deliberately screwed dishes to the pass to test chefs’ quality control.

As I’m sure many of you are aware, Michael had a spotty run at life since his time on Hell’s Kitchen, so I suppose if you were angry enough at him for his mild shenanigans, it didn’t work out swimmingly for him. Still, he was by no means a villain in his season, just someone who knew the game and how to play it. Never caused any drama, never fought with other contestants, and never technically broke the rules so much as stress-tested them, the results of which can be found next season where pass-sabotages are built-in and Ramsay pretty much decides when, where and who to eliminate regardless of who gets nominated.

Nadir: His signature dish wasn’t cleaned, he had roe in his salmon. Honestly, this just proves how irrelevant the signature dishes are until they become a challenge. Carolann got a glowing review only to fail to make it to episode 2, Michael improperly preps his protein and dominates the season.

Mitigating factor: Became pretty good buds with Jimmy by the end of the season.

CONCLUSION:

And that wraps up Season 1. A strange beast of a season, but I think it’s a worthy one. If you aren’t married to the current format of Hell’s Kitchen and want something quieter and more understated than the drama explosions and goofy confessionals of today’s Hell’s Kitchen, this might be your vibe.

Up next, we’re going to be discussing Season 2, featuring the first battle of the sexes that just happens to coincide with one of the shittiest blue teams of the entire show to this very day.

Sunday, April 27, 2025

work in progress

 

It’s time to get hardcore, because we’re going to talk about the 15 Most Brutal Dragonball and Dragonball Z Fights. See, when I say brutal, I’m talking about graphic violence, but I’m also talking about circumstances, context, and the impact the fight has on the plot. Not just fights that make you go “damn,” and nor am I talking about individual violent parts. Yes, we all cringed when Krillin was shish-kabobbed by Frieza or when Yamcha got a hole through his chest, but those weren’t fights. Those weren’t prolonged exchanges between two fighters who were trying to get in their licks as part of an arc that has provided a satisfying reason for the square-up to happen. THOSE are the ones I’m here to talk about.

Real quick before I get started: I’ve excluded GT, Super, Daima, the movies and the video games for various reasons. Either I’m not experienced enough with those series or I don’t want to count them because they aren’t canon. Maybe in the future I’ll talk about the most brutal fights in those, or perhaps do an update video where I pepper in fights from those into this already existing list. Kind of like how the Bravo 100 Scariest Movie Moments list was usurped by the Shudder 101 Scariest Movie Moments list. Enough with the chat, let’s get to the list, starting with:

15. GOKU VS. ANDROID 19

Oh, man, we are starting off with a heavy one, I could have justifiably put this one higher on the list. Okay—imagine you’re having a heart attack, or if you can’t, remember the sickest you’ve ever been. Now, you’re just starting to feel the effects of your illness when you have to lace up and fight against an automaton who is out to absorb your energy and crush your life out of you.

Goku gives a strong start here, but it’s obvious to the smarter Z fighters and to the audience almost immediately that Goku isn’t fighting the way he usually does. He’s fighting the way he might during the middle of the fight when it’s gotten serious and he’s already taken some injuries. Think about the middle of the Frieza fight, when he was trying to keep up with Frieza at 50% power and just getting dunked on. The difference is 19 hasn’t landed a hit in the first half of the fight, but then, why does Goku seem so… exhausted? So gassed, desperate even? He doesn’t have that confident smirk, that mid-fight banter with his opponent, there’s no warming up or styling, Goku’s love of the fight has been replaced with this deadly urgency to just power through, all the while 19 takes hit after hit but gets back up, unencumbered by the damage he’s taken.

The brutality here is just as psychological as it is physical, but after Goku accidentally gives 19 a free energy boost with his Kamehameha wave, the problem becomes clear—Goku is fighting in the middle of a heart attack. The virus Trunks warned him about struck later than anticipated, and Goku is fighting his own body’s disintegration more than he’s fighting the android. It’s a devastating sequence as Goku winds up underneath 19 with the Super Saiyan beaten out of him, unable to do more than grasp at his would-be murderer’s hand as his lifeforce is drained from him, his certain death only postponed by an interference from another worst enemy.

14. KING PICCOLO VS. GOKU (ROUND 1)

It’s rare for Goku to take a serious beating in the Dragonball anime, so when it does happen you know things are getting dire. Unlike in Z, where he’s absent for several episodes at a time and the story gradually shifts focus to his son and to other characters, Goku is the main man all the way in the preceding series, and we experience the world through his perspective so much more than anyone else’s.

So for our main set of eyes to be so hopelessly outmatched against this fresh new arc villain, this is frightening. It’s one thing for Goku to get beaten by someone like Jackie Chun or Tien in the middle of his Heel-Face Turn, because we know at the end of the day it’s just sport, he’s not out to save the world and he’s not fighting for his life. But here? King Piccolo is a demon, he’s been described as such, and the tone has just shifted into much darker territory with the death of Krillin. We’re already coming into this fight thrown off-kilter by such a tragic event—main good guys dying has not become commonplace yet. This is the first time the dragon balls are needed to just resurrect a member of the main cast.

Despite a decent opening combo that puts King Piccolo on his ass, once the warm-up is over, there’s no disputing who the king is on this battlefield. Goku is blasted, rag-dolled, humiliated, thrashed, and made to tremble in fear in a way we’ve never seen before. Not against Mercenary Tao, not against General Blue, not against any villain he’s dealt with. The ante has been upped dramatically, the drama elevated, and when the fight ends with Goku’s body bereft of a heartbeat while the rain pours and King Piccolo gets his hands on another dragon ball… doesn’t it feel like it could be for real, even if just for a second?

13. SECOND-FORM FRIEZA VS. GOHAN

Gohan is already having a bad time on Namek. He’s been taking hits and hiding in foxholes for what can be counted as days on the planet with no night-time, and at half the age his father started going on adventures, he has already encountered the likes of Vegeta, the Ginyu Force, and now the terror of the universe himself, Frieza. A name that might as well be spoken in the same tone as Voldemort, the champion of arc villains. There have been many more powerful characters introduced in Dragonball Z and media afterwards, but none that have inspired so much dread, not just fear, but terror.

And Akira Toriyama didn’t write checks he couldn’t cash. Frieza is that scary, and we see this in his cold-blooded torture of Gohan. It’s a brief fight, in fact it’s the bare minimum of what could constitute a fight, but since Gohan himself instigated it in a rage to rescue his friend, I think it can be counted. Much like the first two entries on this list, the hero gets his brief moment of ass-whooping, knocking Frieza to the ground and tossing a ki haymaker that lands direct on Frieza. It’s just Gohan’s misfortune that his rage state disappears and when the smoke clears, Frieza stands with a scowl, admitting that Gohan’s attack hurt. And as Goku learned, when Frieza tells you that your attack hurt him, don’t take it as a compliment. Take it as a promise that it’s your turn.

A quick combo by Frieza ends with the much taller, much more threatening fighter crushing Gohan’s head into the ground. I have to imagine Gohan had flashbacks to this moment when Videl’s head was about to be turned into smut on Spopovich’s boot, and if you think THAT little scrap won’t make the list, I have a goddamn Snake Way to sell your ass. It’s so cruel and so dark because Gohan just wanted to rescue his friend, and he did the only thing he could do to provide Dende the chance to bring him back. As Goku sensed the decline in power and Vegeta watched, disgusted despite his own evil deeds, Frieza proved once again who the most disgustingly villainous entity in Z is.

12. PICCOLO JR. VS. GOKU

As the first entrant in this list where both fighters are equal and both get their serious, crippling blows on one another, Piccolo Jr. and Goku stands not just as simply a nasty brawl, but a multi-part banger serving as a fitting transition point between the light-hearted adventuring of Son Goku and friends and the titanic planet-devouring space epic of Z. When Piccolo Jr. uses his enormous ki attack that can be seen from hundreds of miles away to not just destroy, but erase, the ring of the World Martial Arts Tournament, it’s a signal that the simple hand-trading exchanges of OG Dragonball are massively evolving.

The damage to both fighters, the blood and the violence and the pain, is hard to understate. At one point, Piccolo expands to the size of an Oozaru to try and crush Goku, who takes this as a welcome opportunity to fly straight into Piccolo’s body and rescue the small porcelain bottle containing the guardian of the Earth, releasing him from his bottle prison. Yeah, this show got fucking weird, even later in the series when the comedy was increasingly phased out. But that’s all to say, even before the Buu saga with Goku and Vegeta’s journey to the center of Majin Buu—almost his colon, too--we are already getting Magic School Bus trips inside of main arc villains before the first Saiyan has touched down to Earth!

I think the brutal part of this fight that people remember the most is the part where Piccolo has nearly been counted out of the fight after Goku lands a heavy combo ending with a Kamehameha that leaves Piccolo half-covered in dirt with his mouth agape in agony. The announcer makes it to 9 as Goku is prematurely celebrating, and then Piccolo leaps into sitting position like a horror movie villain getting in one last scare, blasting a hole through Goku’s shoulder that pierces and burns bone, muscle and skin. Goku screeches in agony, and even if Piccolo did miss all Goku’s vital organs—yes, Piccolo, all of them—the pain is clearly excruciating, made even more so when Piccolo starts attacking and digging into that spot with elbows and stomps. What was once just a fight has degraded into two exhausted beasts taking turns landing the most vicious blows they can, like two antagonists at the end of a Scream film stabbing each other to make the alibi look good.

All I have to say, it’s a good thing the cheat code senzu beans were introduced beforehand, because Goku was primed to spend the better part of a year in the hospital, and we know Roshi doesn’t do well visiting friends in hospitals.

HONORABLE MENTION 1: SSJ2 GOHAN VS. PERFECT CELL

There are a few fights I want to talk about that didn’t make the list, starting with this one. The ass-whooping Cell takes at the hands of the newly-transformed Gohan is a sight to behold. Even though you can count on one hand the number of strikes Gohan lands overall, Cell is damaged so thoroughly that he coughs up mouthfuls of blood, loses nearly all of his limbs (no, Piccolo, nearly all of them), and even vomits up an entire Cyborg, setting in motion the final fateful moments of an arc ending the way Future Trunks tried so hard to avoid: with Goku dead. And then he gets blasted through the chest, that probably wasn’t part of the plan either.

11. CELL VS. ANDROID 17

One of my favorite DBZ VHS tapes to watch and watch and watch until my parents were ready to strangle me was Imperfect Cell – 17’s End. It had four episodes starting with He’s Here and ending with Say Goodbye, 17. So many events occur in those four episodes, it’s perfect in how little filler there is. Piccolo and 17’s brawl concludes with Cell entering the battlefield, almost killing Piccolo, battling Android 16, absorbing 17 and evolving to his Semi-Perfect form, and ending off with Tien spamming the Tri-Beam while 16 and 18 escape the battlefield.

In between these events, one of the most one-sided and nasty beatdowns in all of Z occurs in the form of Imperfect Cell vs. Android 17. What kills me about the original Funi edit is the way they structured this sequence, it’s so nasty. After Piccolo’s carcass gets tossed to the briny depths, 17, who we already have seen is inadequate against Cell’s power, does his level best to defend himself. We end the initial scene with 17 dodging Cell’s tail strikes, we pivot to Bulma talking with the Z Fighters on Roshi’s island about Krillin meeting up with her and her deciding to turn it into a race between Krillin’s flight and her plane’s, and when we come back… dear God. We return to a beating so gargantuan that even after all these years, all of my viewings of that VHS tape have made it to where I can recall it from memory.

17 is rag dolled from stage right, Cell comes up on him and stomps his face over and over before a humiliating tail slap into midair. Before 17 can even land, Cell does a flying leap over 17’s arcing body and delivers a blow to the stomach before stomping his gut and landing three solid punches to the face. He then grabs 17 up by his Fred from Scooby-Doo looking orange doo-rag and rears his fist back, slamming it so hard into 17’s solar plexus that we hear his voice malfunction for a second. Finally, Cell drops him on the ground, and as he’s on his hands and knees trying to recover, Cell delivers an elbow to the back of the head, mercifully ending one of the craziest fucking combos in any DBZ fight.

Can it even be called a fight? It’s more of a torture session at this juncture of the confrontation. 17 is just moaning and gasping in pain, even Cell seems affected by 17’s agonized vocalizations, telling him he never meant for this to be so humiliating for him. And that’s perhaps the most brutal part of this brief fight, 17 was so cool and confident ever since his awakening so many episodes ago, it has the same effect as watching one of Vegeta’s many molly-whoppings. The abject shame and indignity create a sort of horror for the viewer as Cell destroys not just 17’s body, but his pride.

10. MAJIN BUU VS. MAJIN VEGETA

Starting off our top 10 right, we’ve got Fat Buu’s fight against Majin Vegeta. Fat Buu has already caught a body with Dabura—well, ate a body, I guess—and he’s laid out both Gohan and the Supreme Kai looking no worse for wear. Majin Vegeta has “betrayed” the master who was never his master by blowing up Babidi’s ship, stranding him on Earth, which is a brilliant move if you think about it. Babidi probably can’t breathe in space, so he won’t be in any hurry to blow up the Earth if space travel is out of the question. But I digress.

Vegeta tees off on Buu, who does what he did in the battle with Supreme Kai and his proper match with Dabura—let the opponent tee off first. Vegeta unleashes a flurry of attacks that winds up turning Majin Buu into a nest of cup-holders. Take this man to a Super Bowl party and lay him in front of the TV, everyone can put their red dixie cup of beer into one of the holes Vegeta just punched into him. But as we’ve come to expect now, Vegeta’s attack accomplishes nothing whatsoever.

No, it’s the next two events in this fight that put it on this list. First of all, after Buu powers up so hard it can be seen from space (big deal, that shit happens at least once per arc), he wraps Vegeta in a cocoon of his own skin and just beats him severely, kicking him, ass-stomping him, punching him over and over in the face, stomping him, and it takes the interference of Super Saiyans Trunks and Goten to hold off the eventual death of Trunks’s pops.

But now we come to the end of the fight, where Vegeta powers up so hard that he explodes himself, reducing Buu to piles of flesh. And yes, if you’re familiar with the show, those piles come to life and recombine into the Fat Buu, good as new. But it is not only to say that this moment was the conclusion of Vegeta’s emotional arc from someone who only cares about himself to someone who has people to fight for, it’s also just a very painful way to die. It must be, right? It’s the DBZ equivalent of having a heart attack while taking a shit, that’s the closest analogue—heh, “anal log”—I can think of. And the fact that it meant absolutely nothing, that Buu wound up not taking any permanent damage? This is psychological brutality at its finest, it’s right up there with Chiaotzu blowing himself up against Nappa and accomplishing nothing for his troubles. Sacrificing yourself if you’re as selfish as Vegeta is hard enough, to come to find out you didn’t even do anything? Yikes.

9. FRIEZA VS. NAIL

Here’s one of these fights that you can only call a fight because both fighters are trying to fight. Because to call Nail’s performance against Frieza “putting up a fight” is like calling someone trying to catch a city-sized asteroid “putting up a fight.” The word “fight” has lost all meaning in my brain, I’m a bad writer.

Erm, anyway, Nail getting roffle-stomped is one of the only two things Nail is known for, the other being his fusion with Piccolo that allows him some indirect get-back on Frieza. You need to keep in mind, with appearances that Frieza makes on this list, this is the villain that destroyed the power scaling of the Dragonball franchise. No other character to this day, except maybe Beerus, showed up and was immediately just so much stronger than every other character.

This man’s max power is 120 fucking million. For context, Vegeta, the villain from just one arc ago, had to become an Oozaru—a giant-ass King Kong ape with Saiyan armor—to hit 180,000. You can fit 6666 Oozaru Vegetas from the last arc in a single goddamn Frieza. That’s what Nail, with his roughly 80,000 power level, is dealing with. Frieza in his first form, he maxes out at 530,000. That’s over six Nails, so hey, maybe Nail’s got a shot, right? Look, I know we know power levels are bullshit, but sometimes they aren’t. When you have a differential like this, they aren’t.

This is the first time we see Frieza in a fight, so already we’re on edge, knowing this guy can just blow people up with his ki with no exertion at all. What is his first move of his first on-screen fight? Nothing too special, he just grabs Nail and fucking rips off his forearm, leaving him screaming in pain. I would say that it’s fortunate that Nail was able to regrow the arm, but against Frieza, he wasn’t going to be doing a goddamn thing with it.

The fight is just full of humiliations like this, and many of them are exclusive to the anime. These animators decided to spend a huge chunk of filler time straight-up torturing Nail. There’s this one part where Frieza places his hand to Nail’s back and somehow bulges his chest out until he looks like Cell powering up to Super Saiyan Grade 3. It looks insane, and Nail is just shrieking in pain as this is going on. You just picture the dude’s spine being pushed into his ribcage, his organs just dispersing to either corner of his chest as Frieza holds back just enough power to not fatally wound Nail. Because, after all, he needs to get that Namekian dragon ball password, so this isn’t even an instance where Frieza’s having fun, this is just him in enhanced interrogation mode. Not that it isn’t fun for Frieza, you understand—check out his grin as the stump that once held Nail’s forearm gushes blood, Frieza is literally an evil child with a stray cat.

By the time Frieza gets done with Nail, he is a bloody green pile of detritus on the Namekian soil. He did himself and his kind proud though, as the last of his kind, because unlike our last entry this brutality didn’t go to waste. The Z Fighters successfully summoned the dragon with Dende’s help as Frieza was distracted. This revelation, delivered from Nail with a devious, bleeding grin, sends Frieza into a fit, and I think Frieza left him here like this to torture him further. Shouldn’t have done that, man.

8. NAPPA VS. TIEN

This is early Z, where the fights are still pretty ki-less and much more about the physicality of the warriors and choreography. Nappa opens this fight with a very similar move to Frieza’s fight with Nail, only he doesn’t even grab the goddamn arm to rip it off—he is able to PUNCH Tien’s forearm clean off his body, and when I say clean, there isn’t any hanging flesh or anything. It’s just a perfectly even cut, like someone sliced a log of pepperoni into two halves.

Tien, at his absolute freshest, straight off a year of training for this shit, immediately loses an arm trying to block a punch. It’s unbelievable—it’s like someone practicing at basketball for a year, and then showing up to their first game and having their femur break trying to do a jumpshot. It’s like the show is saying, “you fucking dumbass, you actually watched all of that filler? You really sat down and wasted your sorry ass life like that? You little nine-year-old piece of shit, get a load of this!”

From there, Tien just gets served time and again. Nappa launches this man in the air, bonks him to the ground, kicks the shit out of him, he basically serves as Nappa’s fleshy punching bag for the brief duration of this battle. Once again, this is an instance where the only reason you can call this a battle is because the guy getting his shit pushed in is still throwing hands as best he can. I always think about the shot Tien throws that Nappa dodges, causing the shot to hit a rock formation and crumble it. I guess we needed a reminder that Tien has super-powers and is actually a fighter instead of, y’know, a pile of dogshit wearing a fighter Halloween costume.

Krillin tries to step in and is rewarded with another demonstration of Nappa’s seemingly endless power: he swipes his hand and puts a big-ass hole in the ground right in front of him, catching Chiaotzu in the blast, or so it seems. It’s remarked that the hole seems to have no bottom, but I don’t really like that, because much later in the Frieza arc the namesake of said arc seemingly cuts Namek in half with a single beam. If Nappa can basically put a bottomless hole in the ground, with his pissant 4,000 power level, it really makes Frieza’s feat not so impressive. DBZ is full of shit like that, one arc this guy’s power is incredible and he can put endless holes in the Earth, next arc, that guy’s a flea compared to this guy who can, uh, put endless holes in Namek.

Chiaotzu explodes himself on Nappa’s back in a suicidal desperation move to destroy the Saiyan, and man, it could have at least blown the back out of Nappa’s armor, maybe scuffed him a little. It did absolutely jack shit, leaving Tien no other choice:

Tien’s last try is to use a Tri-Beam, which Nappa blocks with just a bit of damage to his armor. I guess that’s better than Chiaotzu, who also gave his life to accomplish nothing, but at least Tien damaged the armor and can be wished back with the Earth dragon balls. I find that the theme going into this third of the list is sacrifice—Majin Vegeta’s sacrifice, Tien’s sacrifice, and even Nail’s, although at least Nail’s worked. Still, this is the bleakest fight in the Saiyan saga for sure. The situation feels just so hopeless without Goku there, with Krillin and Piccolo too weak and Gohan too weak and frightened to scuff the weakest of the two Saiyans.

7. KID BUU VS. VEGETA

This is a special instance because I’m doing a little bit of surgery here. These are two different battles that I’m piecing together as one, because between them both, Goku interferes and starts to fight Kid Buu again and also Vegeta gets wished back to life, meaning stakes on the second go-round are, well, not increased, but changed. Because in DBZ, a soul can be destroyed even if it still has its body. So, if Kid Buu had destroyed Vegeta as a dead person, he would be permanently gone. Now, though, Vegeta has gotten his life back, so Kid Buu can put him right back in that halo if he’s of a mind. Fortunately, there are so many other opps on this planet for Kid Buu to deal with, Vegeta’s never alone with the bastard for too long.

Both dead and alive, Vegeta takes a fucking shredding here. Kid Buu does not play nicely with him, probably hoping he’ll be just as much fun as the other full-blooded Saiyan he’s been mixing it up with. Vegeta probably loses enough blood here, he could give every human on Earth an injection of Saiyan blood to form the new Saiyan race, once they get revived that is.

A few of the notable moments? Well, for starters, Vegeta takes a ki blast directly in the face, just after he got a classic DBZ gut-punch where you can see the puncher’s hand cave in the punchee’s back. There’s another moment where Kid Buu elbows Vegeta on the top of the head, thankfully missing that halo since it has to float above Vegeta’s big-ass hair. And also, look at the face Vegeta makes when Kid Buu has him by the throat. Any time someone talks about these fights on YouTube, they have this shit in the thumbnail, because it is one of the goofiest faces Vegeta ever makes.

I also have to talk about what little work Vegeta manages to get off, just so we can all be reminded that this is one of the strongest dudes in the show. He blasts off Kid Buu’s legs a bunch of times and gets in a few punches. Well, shit, that was easier than I thought, I got it all in a sentence, go me. Well, there was also an explosion wave against a whole bunch of mini-Kid Buus (kid-Kid Buus?), followed by a ki blast spam that, you’re going to want to sit down for this news, did ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. I know, right, usually that shit doesn’t work, but this time it didn’t work!

Ultimately, this sacrifice on Vegeta’s part goes off much better than his attempted sacrifice against Fat Buu. His only job here was to stall Buu for long enough for Goku to do the shit he had to do. Once again, it helps that every other person on that planet, even goddamn Hercule, pitched in to help keep Buu at bay, but Vegeta contributed the most, and goddamn it that counts for something. But it doesn’t mean that it also wasn’t a truly grueling and unpleasant experience to watch Vegeta get blown back by Kid Buu. Every blow Kid Buu landed felt like it could have been lethal, Vegeta by the end of it straight-up had blood coming out of his scalp, and the day Mr. Hercule Satan has to come carry your ass out of the line of fire is a day that you got more Ls than someone writing an essay about the La Li Lu Le Lo.

HONORABLE MENTION 2: VEGETA VS. ANDROID 19

This is perhaps one of the most iconic Vegeta moments in the entire show. Vegeta has just gone Super Saiyan, and he shows off his newfound power by issuing one of the most vicious smackdowns ever. Not one blow is wasted—each hit is a power shot that either sends 19 away or has him bleeding from his face. The battle concludes with 19 having both of his hands ripped off and being blown away by Vegeta’s Big Bang attack, another debut from Vegeta in this fight. Only in DBZ could you accurately describe an android being destroyed as “gory.”

It's especially rewarding because this comes right after 19 has just butchered a virus-weakened Goku. We knew 19 was free eats because Goku was dominating their fight even mid-heart attack at first, 19 was just not built for the task at hand and it showed. Having the healthy, invigorated Vegeta bash 19 like so much mechanical junk made everyone watching at the time feel like the future was changing. Which it was, just not in the way anyone could have seen coming.

6. MAJIN BUU VS. SUPREME KAI

Ooh, boy. Okay. This one.

Let’s begin with the fact that this is Supreme Kai’s one and only fight in the entirety of Z, and as far as I’m aware, the entire franchise. Actually, I take that back, he’s shown in a flashback fighting Buff Buu and getting his shit rocked then, too. Thing is, people rag on the Supreme Kai for being a wuss, but that’s because his one and only showing is against Majin Buu, who was able to put both Dabura and Gohan down for the count with a single bonk on the head. Supreme Kai takes the same hit and gets right back up to fire a huge ki blast right through Majin Buu. It doesn’t do a goddamn thing, but he didn’t just stay down either. I think people don’t put enough respect on Supreme Kai’s name, the dude stood up to Buu for a while.

Of course, that was to his detriment, as it just made his subsequent ass-whooping all the more painfully prolonged. Listen, when I see fights like this, I struggle to imagine that Buu was all that innocent and I can’t believe that Hercule was able to turn him good as easily as he did, because oh my God, Buu was a fucking bully here. If there was a toilet on this battlefield, Kai’s head would have been taking up residence in there, he’d be getting charged rent for that shit.

Literally the first blow Buu lands in this fight is him clapping Supreme Kai’s cheeks. No, I did not misuse the word “literally” in that sentence, Supreme Kai’s cheeks actually get goddamn clapped. Look at him spitting out blood, holy shit, his skull was smashed horizontally like a goddamn Looney Tunes character! Then Buu clobbers him on the top of the head and dances a little mid-air jig like he won a game of goddamn Fortnite. Unfortunately, his opp returned with a blast through the stomach. As I said earlier, this didn’t do shit, but it’s the thought that counts. Wait, what the hell am I talking about, no it doesn’t!

Supreme Kai then takes a headbutt that puts him right back in the rubble, where Buu soon meets him. It’s here that Buu turns into a goddamn slasher villain, marching slowly up to the Supreme Kai with a grin that either says “I’m going to kill you” or “I really like Lunchables, where is my helmet?” Supreme Kai tries another one of his limp-ass mental ki attacks that accomplishes little else except making Majin Buu look like a Matrix character dodging bullets. A fitting reference for the time period in which this episode debuted in America. Once Buu recovers, he does something he’s going to do several more times during this arc, and imitates the attack that was just used on him.

Yes, much like Goku, Buu can just watch someone do an attack once and master it right away. Buu’s attack is much more potent, and this face Supreme Kai makes scared the shit out of me when I was a kid. It looks like some unseen force is stretching him like he’s a piece of taffy, and he is in some real pain after this shit. He basically doesn’t get back up again until after Vegeta uses his explosion suicide attack against Buu, and this is not helped by the fact that Buu ass-stomps the total shit out of him, turning his spine into a curved over-ripe banana and emptying him of any fight he might still have had.

This fight is all Goku and Vegeta’s fault, and in hindsight, Supreme Kai may have been better off just calling Goku’s bluff at the Tournament ring earlier. Yeah, Supreme Kai may have gotten the shit blasted out of him, but… well, actually, there really isn’t an upside. Goku and Vegeta were just going to do whatever the hell they wanted, and I think personally that Goku should have had to report back to King Yemma once his time on Earth ran out so it could be decided if he needs to just be sent to hell for the good of the universe and its inhabitants.

Seriously, what good deed has Goku performed lately that could justify him knowingly bringing Buu back to life by not only taking Vegeta’s bait, but not going Super Saiyan 3 and ending the fight immediately so that Buu could never be revived? Thanks to the two dumbass full-blooded Saiyans, Majin Buu woke up and destroyed Earth and all of its inhabitants, but not before fighting God Himself and pushing the poor bastard’s shit in so hard it almost came out of his mouth.

5. OOZARU VEGETA VS. GOKU

I debated back and forth with just putting the entire Goku vs. Vegeta fight in this slot, but the reason I ultimately decided to go with this specific part where Vegeta turns into the Oozaru is because most of the preceding fight before this is just a regular banger. It’s an awesome fight that lives and has lived rent-free in many a DBZ fan’s head ever since the first time they saw it, but as far as brutality, the most it has is one of Goku’s combos against Vegeta that ultimately doesn’t do that much damage, followed by Goku’s Kaioken x4 Kamehameha that also does some damage, but falls far short of taking Vegeta out of the fight.

This, on the other hand, is a massacre. It’s probably some of the most Goku has ever suffered in such a short time span. What’s genius about it is how we’re set up for it. Yajirobe was just talking to Goku, giving himself a backslap for all the nothing he contributed, but when he tried giving Goku his own backslap, Goku let out a screech of pain. Yajirobe being far weaker than Goku, and that slap not even having a lot of mustard on it, you knew what King Kai said was true—Goku had come to the verge of destroying his own body with that last attack. To make things worse, as Goku predicted would happen, Vegeta returned to the battlefield to finish the job.

Us knowing already that a simple attaboy slap is enough to send Goku nearly manic with agony, when we hear that Vegeta is going to transform into the Great Ape, we are terrified for him. I’m sure many of us have experienced the feeling of something large—be it a person or an object—landing on us and hurting us. Maybe a friend body-slammed us a little too hard while play wrestling, maybe we accidentally pulled something heavy down on ourselves as we were trying to move it, maybe we were lifting a cinderblock and dropped it on our own foot. We all can relate to a crushing sensation, but when you add in the fact that Goku is already in full bodily agony that we can’t imagine? This can only be the opening of a door to a level of suffering unheard-of to any character in the show at this point.

At first, right after Vegeta transforms, Goku finds a second wind. Maybe it’s the sheer adrenaline of having a giant ape trailing his ass, but he starts doing acrobatics, slipping behind pillars, at one point he realizes that the thing that killed Grandpa Gohan must’ve been his very own Oozaru transformation, back when he still had his tail and Earth still had a moon. Vowing to make up for what happened to his beloved grandfather, Goku begins to charge a Spirit Bomb that Vegeta almost completely cancels out with a beam from his mouth. The only damage Goku’s able to deal in between running for his life and taking on sudden onset guilt from killing his own grandfather is a Solar Flare and a beam to Vegeta’s eye. At this point, Vegeta feels as if he’s underperformed, and he wants his get-back badly. He gets Goku right where he wants him, and it’s time to repay Goku for the pain he’s inflicted.

To put it about as mildly as I can, Oozaru Vegeta does his job. We see Goku get his legs stomped all to hell and we see him picked up and squeezed like a stress ball—look at Goku’s mouth and listen to his screams. We’re in damn near Hostel territory, someone needs to send Eli Roth a script for Hostel 4 that’s just a single continued shot of Goku’s “fight” with Oozaru Vegeta. It gets so bad, Krillin, Gohan and even goddamn Yajirobe have to combine forces to get Vegeta to stop his sheer violation of Goku. Yajirobe has to cut Vegeta’s tail off while he’s distracted to get him to stop squeezing Goku’s intestines out through his face. If a surgeon were to open up Goku’s stomach after this shit, it would look like a can of Chef Boyardee raviolis put through a paper shredder, sauce and all. And that, ladies, gentlemen, folks of a different persuasion, is why this is the second most brutal fight of the Saiyan saga.

4. GOKU AND PICCOLO VS. RADITZ

“Raditz?” You might be saying, a smirk on your face not unlike that of Raditz’s. “His weak ass beats out Oozaru Vegeta?” And to that I have to reply, you’ve let Team Four Star and a bunch of other Internet people meme you into forgetting what a menace this man was during his very brief arc. It took the combined efforts of Earth’s two strongest warriors and the son of one of Earth’s strongest warriors to bring this man down, and the only reason they succeeded was a combination of sheer luck and sacrifice.

We knew Raditz was a beast from his first moment on Earth, catching a farmer’s bullet in midair and flicking it back toward him. It’s like a twisted photo negative of Goku’s first encounter with Bulma, where Bulma shoots him in the head but it does nothing except hurt him a bit. Here, it’s Goku’s brother, and not only is he not hurt at all, he takes an innocent human life the way Goku might take out a wolf or a centipede for his dinner. The parallels are already apparent here, as Raditz then proceeds to come into confrontation with Piccolo, tanking a point-blank ki blast that probably would have put Goku at death’s door if it hit him off-guard.

Finally, Raditz flexes his powers pre-fight by crippling Goku for several minutes with no more than a knee to the gut. Goku, the hero of the world, its savior multiple times, so powerful he can punch you several times without you even seeing it, able to fire beams in a weakened state that push him high into the atmosphere, takes a single knee from his big brother and all he can do is groan in pain and beg Raditz not to take his son. These are the stakes given to us in the opening minutes of Dragonball Z, we are not eased in, this show floors it at the starting line.

After Goku and Piccolo have teamed up, they track Raditz down by sensing his ki, finding that he has stuck Gohan inside of his space-pod. With Goku and Piccolo having arrived and thrown down the gauntlet, Raditz declares he doesn’t want a weakling like Kakarot on his side anyway, and the boxing commences.

Any time I think of this fight, I think of all the interesting, sometimes off-beat ways Raditz deals with two opponents. At one point, he flashes into this laying position and kicks both Goku and Piccolo away. He also elbows them each in the back. He even fires a ki blast at each of them as they try to approach, and for their trouble, they become a three-armed duo as Piccolo’s left arm is severed. It’s obvious that everything Goku and Piccolo throw at their opponent isn’t even challenging him, never mind hurting him. Even starting off the fight with no weighted clothing, Raditz seems untouchable.

So what seals the deal on this fight being the fourth most brutal? Well, Raditz gets to fight little brother by himself when Piccolo starts to charge what he says is a devastating attack that was meant for Goku. Goku proceeds to get washed, landing nothing and being peppered with strike after strike. See, this is what I’m talking about—Raditz only looks like shit when you compare him to the two much stronger Saiyans and the Saibamen, which, okay, it is a little ridiculous that they can grow fighters almost as strong as Raditz, I’ll admit that. In any case, here, in the first few episodes of Z, Raditz provides a similar feeling of hopelessness for the heroes that villains like Frieza would later inspire.

Eventually, two major events set the stage for Raditz’s fall, and they are the major factor in this fight hitting near the top. Raditz takes a massive blow from Gohan’s first-ever slip into a rage state, something he’d been building up to for some episodes, but which finally explodes here. Then, Goku, having just been talked out of holding Raditz’s tale and gotten some broken ribs for his trouble, grabs his brother in a full-nelson and is then shish-kabobbed by the Special Beam Cannon along with him. The two brothers are dead, bleeding on the ground from softball-sized holes in their stomachs, setting the tone for the rest of the series.

3. SPOPOVICH VS. VIDEL

Not only is this the nastiest fight in the Buu saga, but by far, it’s also the most sudden tonal shift in Z. Before the World Tournament started, there was nothing to indicate that an evil force was present. Goku was back for a day of fun, sporting competition with friends and family alike, he had just met his youngest son Goten in one of the most heartwarming scenes in the show, and as the heroes came together to enter the competition, it felt less like a saga in Dragonball Z and more like the easygoing first Tournament arc in its prequel series.

Even when we get introduced to Yamu and Spopovich, they seem a far cry from the poised, intelligent villains we’ve gotten used to. They’re both these grimacing, grunting men who look like they can barely hold it together. When Videl and Spopovich get matched up, we figure, “oh, it’ll be fine. Videl can box, we already know that, and even if there’s any trouble, she can fly!”

The two get in the ring, and keep in mind, Piccolo just found out that the Supreme Kai, essentially the god of this universe, is here and Piccolo has been asked to keep this under wraps. So we know something strange is going on, but we’re put at ease with Videl’s first combo. She has Spopovich, this big, clumsy and unskilled man, laid out and the announcer starts a count right away.

Then Spopovich gets up.

Videl and him trade some attacks for a little while before Videl is once again able to get the drop on him and put him on the floor face-first. The crowd cheers.

Then Spopovich gets up.

It cuts to two of the men who participated in the last tournament talking about how Spopovich has changed, and it’s not only in his looks. Meanwhile, Videl stops him in a grab attempt and lifts him over her head, tossing him back on the ring floor, neck first. The announcer all but declares Videl the winner.

Then Spopovich gets up.

Every time this man comes back, the mood of the crowd and Videl herself shifts into increased bewilderment. How is this regular man who seems out of his depth against Videl still getting up? Eventually, after Spopovich gets off a few hits against a tired Videl, even managing to almost ring her out, and after Goku states that he can’t sense Spopovich’s energy, Videl runs out of patience and over-commits to a kick that turns Spopovich’s head completely around. He falls to the floor once again, dead. Somberly, as the crowd and Videl look on in shock, the tournament announcer states that Videl will be disqualified, putting an end to the promising young fighter’s shot at the title of World Champion.

Then Spopovich gets up. To a standing position. He turns his head and lifts it, setting it back to normal.

At this point, it’s obvious to all the Z Fighters that Videl is in danger, and while Videl herself is shocked, she refuses to quit, continuing to trade hits with Spopovich. She takes enough damage to decide its time for a break, so she flies out of the ring and that’s when her opponent reveals his own ability to fly. Then he puts out his hand and charges a weak ki wave, making Videl plummet back down.

What ensues is a sight so grotesque, I remember even when I was a kid and a big DBZ fan, watching the TV edited version was enough to creep me out. Spopovich pummels Videl repeatedly, kneeing her in the face—in the manga, she loses some teeth here—and deliberately saving her from a surefire ring out just to continue beating her.

A wave of terror hits the crowd and the announcer begs Videl openly to forfeit the match, but Videl refuses. Her pride has turned against her into being the thing that’s tethering her to potential oblivion. We have no idea how far Spopovich is willing to take his brutality, we only know he lost against Videl’s father last tournament. Videl becomes unable to defend herself, with Spopovich placing her on his knee and beating her face. The crowd and the people running the tournament hesitate to stop the onslaught until, when Spopovich places his boot on her head and Videl begins to weep in fear, shame and agony, Gohan intervenes. But Yamu gets there first, seemingly disgusted at Spopovich’s behavior, and tells him to just finish the match. Videl is unceremoniously kicked out of the ring, and her relevance to the plot as a fighter is gone.

The worst part about this, I think, is the fact it took so long for anybody to put a stop to it, long after it went from fight to mauling. It leaves a nasty flavor in my mouth, reminding me of real-world scenarios where somebody is being severely mistreated, perhaps even assaulted, in public and everyone is watching, but nobody is helping them. It’s true that Videl refused to forfeit, but by the time Spopovich saved her from ring-out, his intentions should have been read as they were—cruel and malicious. In any case, Videl’s foolhardiness is not new to DBZ, we see fighters like Vegeta or Tien keep getting up when they should just stay down, but Videl’s is a special case because she wound up against odds she could never stack up to. She is a dragon ball level fighter who got in over her head against a super-powered sadist with a grudge.

2. RECOOME VS. GOHAN

The honor of being our runner-up goes to arguably the most bleak moment in the entire Namek saga. Let me set the stage for you: Goku has still not arrived on Namek yet, and Frieza has called in the elite Ginyu Force, his strongest minions, to bring scouters and reign in Vegeta and the earthlings. Vegeta, Krillin and Gohan have been forced into an uneasy alliance, despite having different goals involving the dragon balls, because Vegeta sensed the Ginyu Force and knew he couldn’t defeat them by himself. The Ginyu Force take all seven dragonballs back from Vegeta, so Frieza is now in possession of all seven balls, leaving Vegeta and the earthlings to deal with every Ginyu Force member save for Captain Ginyu.

And for being completely outclassed, the three of them have put up a fierce fight. The weakest member, Guldo, was easy pickings for Vegeta while he was distracted with the two earthlings, and the next to square up was Recoome. Here, despite opening their one-on-one bout with maybe the finest combo he’s ever used on an opponent, Vegeta is just not strong enough to really hurt Recoome, and within a span of minutes Recoome renders his Saiyan opponent crippled to the point of uselessness.

The earthlings step in to stop Vegeta from being killed, and Vegeta admonishes them, saying they should have doubled their efforts against Recoome and left him for dead. Let’s pause and think about that for a second. The entire Namek saga has seen Vegeta with blood-red determination to procure the dragonballs and get out from Frieza’s thumb. Pulled out every stop, took out opponents when they were alone, even pulled a sneak maneuver on Frieza’s ship that resulted in him having almost every ball hidden away for himself. But now, with Recoome baring down, with Burter and Jeice observing like smirking vultures, Vegeta has given up hope for his own survival.

That’s what these three were dealing with when the Ginyu Force showed up. And yeah, they became and always were a joke, but at their debut they were untouchable. Only Nail could have beaten anyone in the force not named Ginyu, and he was about to have his hands full with an angry Frieza descending like a reaper on Guru’s lookout.

It doesn’t take long before the combined efforts of Krillin and Gohan are turned to just, well, Gohan. Krillin is taken out of the fight with a single blow, so devastating it paralyzes him. All that’s left to make a stand and keep the chance alive of bringing back the victims of Nappa and Vegeta’s rampage is a single, half-Saiyan child, barely above pre-school age, who in his brief youth so far has faced opponents that would have shaken Kid Goku off like a flea.

The few times Gohan gets off any work on Recoome, it feels like a BB gun being fired at a brick wall. Whereas every blow Recoome lands, and he gets off quite a number, feels like it could be a fight-ending blow. To state the obvious, the height and weight difference is staggering. Calling it David and Goliath would be underselling it—it’s more like a rottweiler vs. an elephant. Yeah, the rottweiler might be strong and even trained to fight, but the elephant is just bigger, and it’s got a stronger hide, it’s just going to win.

Gohan is cursed with Saiyan durability during this fight. Krillin was knocked to his ass with a single kick, there was no prolonged beatdown for him. Gohan does not get that luxury, as Recoome uses hands and feet almost as big as his Kindergarten-age opponent to pound the shit out of Gohan several times, until all he can do is weakly march toward his doom. Gohan gives a nice little preview to Goku’s Super Saiyan speech, declaring he isn’t scared of Recoome and that he is the child of Son Goku. He uses the last of his strength to launch toward Recoome… and Recoome jumps up and lands a kick to Gohan’s neck, audibly breaking it and leaving Gohan blank-eyed on the ground, bleeding from his mouth.

It's one of the most upsetting images in DBZ, because of just how needlessly cruel it is. Gohan is maybe six years old by this point, barely looking more than a foot tall, and Recoome is an enormous, grinning ogre who barely even seems to register the horror of what he’s doing. They already had the dragon balls. They already demonstrated they were stronger than the Earthlings. Even if they insisted upon carrying out Frieza’s orders to kill Vegeta, Krillin and Gohan, the way Recoome prolongs all of their suffering while that big, dumb smile resolutely stays on his face, it made me see Recoome as sadistic and ruthless in a way I hadn’t considered before doing this essay.

Recoome’s propensity to play with his food does come back to bite him and his allies when Goku pulls up on Namek just in the nick of time, using a sensu bean on his paralyzed but somehow still alive son to unbreak his neck, don’t even fucking ask me how that works. Goku and Vegeta get some much-deserved revenge on Recoome, but what haunts me is just how close things were to being unsalvageable. Given another five or ten minutes, Recoome would have a body count to rival Nappa, and Goku would have had to face the terrors of Frieza and Captain Ginyu by himself.